This isn't a sales gimmick. The U.S. National Cancer Institute (NCI) explains it plainly: PAH is created when fat and meat juices drip onto a hot surface or into flames, creating flare-ups and smoke; that smoke carries PAH that deposits back onto the meat's surface. In other words, the main culprit isn't the charcoal — it's the fat droplet landing on it.
The Most Reliable Number
Lee JG's team (Korea Food and Drug Safety Authority) published Food Chemistry a 2016 study comparing many charcoal-grilling methods. Their conclusion: the most important factor creating PAH is smoke rising from fat droplets.
A 2016 Korean study on charcoal-grilled pork and beef found that catching the fat cut the total of 4 PAHs by 48 to 89%, while removing the smoke cut it by 41 to 74%, compared with ordinary grilling.
Lee JG et al. (2016). Food Chemistry 199:632-638. PMID 26776018.
Benzo[a]pyrene, one of the 4 PAHs measured in this study, is a substance IARC classifies as Group 1 in Monograph Vol. 100F (2012). To be clear: IARC explicitly states there is no specific epidemiological data in humans for this substance alone; classification is based on animal experiments and mechanism — so no one should claim "proven in humans."
The cook is also exposed
Not just the meat. Measurements in charcoal BBQ restaurants in Hong Kong showed fine particulate matter PM2.5 reaching 1.167 µg/m³. A Portuguese study tracking 18 grill workers across six cities found PAH metabolites in urine increased 9-fold after a work shift. A vertical chimney and a mechanism that prevents fat from touching the coals are two things that help reduce the smoke blown directly into the cook's face.
And this is the part we don't hide
Blocking fat cannot addresses HCA — a group of compounds formed directly in the meat from high heat, originating from creatine, amino acids and sugars, not from smoke. To reduce HCA you must lower surface temperature and shorten cooking time: the same piece of meat at 150°C for 15 minutes yields about 5.89 ng/g, but at 230°C for 15 minutes jumps to about 675.9 ng/g.
And there are also studies that found no difference: Sumer & Oz (2023, Foods 12(7):1374) compared several cooking methods and cannot found no statistically significant difference in total PAH4/PAH8 (p>0.05). Science hasn't spoken with one voice yet, and we think you should know that.
One thing remains certain: when fat drips onto red-hot coals it smokes — anyone tending a grill sees that with their own eyes. This oven was built so that fat drips into a tray instead of into the fire. Read the full analytical article with 16 sources.













